Skip to content

Lesson 04 · 15 min read

Taxes and Closing Costs on a Commercial Sale

How gain is calculated, how depreciation recapture and capital gains are taxed, what NIIT and FIRPTA mean for a seller, the Florida closing costs to expect, and a full net proceeds estimate.

The price on the contract is the top line. What lands in your account is the bottom line, after closing costs, the loan payoff, prorations, and taxes. Many owners know their price to the dollar and their tax bill only roughly. That gap matters, because the tax plan has to be set before closing. Once the deed records, most options are gone.

This lesson covers how gain is calculated, how each layer of gain is taxed at the federal level, the 3.8% net investment income tax, Florida's tax picture, the closing costs on a Florida commercial sale, FIRPTA withholding for foreign sellers, and a full worked estimate on the Oviedo retail building from Lesson 3.

Education, not tax or legal advice. Tax law changes and depends on your facts, entity, and income. Use this lesson to prepare questions, then confirm every number with your CPA and a Florida attorney before you sign a contract.

How gain is calculated

Amount realized

The sale price, less your selling costs, such as brokerage fees, the seller's title and closing charges, documentary stamp tax if you pay it, and attorney fees. If the buyer assumes your loan, the loan balance is part of the amount realized too.

Adjusted basis

Adjusted basis = original cost (including acquisition costs)
               + capital improvements
               − depreciation taken (or allowable)

Note "or allowable." If you were entitled to depreciation and did not claim it, the IRS generally still reduces your basis as if you had. If you suspect missed depreciation, raise it with your CPA before the sale year, because there may be ways to catch up.

If you acquired the property in a 1031 exchange, your basis generally carries over from the property you gave up, adjusted. Long exchange chains can leave a very low basis. Find your basis records now. Your CPA will need them.

How the gain is taxed: the federal layers

Federal tax on a commercial sale usually comes in layers. Each layer has its own rate.

LayerWhat it isFederal rate
§1245 recaptureDepreciation on personal property and land improvements, often created by a cost segregation studyOrdinary income rates
Unrecaptured §1250 gainStraight-line depreciation taken on the buildingTaxed at a maximum of 25%
Long-term capital gainGain above your original cost, for property held more than one year0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on income
Net investment income taxA separate 3.8% tax under IRC §14113.8% on the amount subject to NIIT

Depreciation recapture on the building

Buildings placed in service after 1986 are depreciated straight-line. When you sell, the gain equal to that depreciation is called unrecaptured §1250 gain. It is taxed at your ordinary rate, but not more than 25%.

Cost segregation and §1245 recapture

If you had a cost segregation study, part of your property was reclassified into shorter-life personal property and land improvements, such as certain electrical, flooring, and site work. That produced bigger deductions early. At sale, depreciation on those §1245 components is generally recaptured as ordinary income, which can be taxed at a higher rate than the 25% building recapture.

Cost segregation is still often worth it. It speeds up deductions and the recapture comes later. But the sale-year bill is larger than many owners expect. See Depreciation, Cost Segregation, and Bonus Depreciation. The S-Corp and cost segregation tax strategy calculator shows the front-end benefit, and this lesson shows the back end.

Long-term capital gain

Gain above the depreciation layers is long-term capital gain if you held the property more than one year. Federal rates are 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your taxable income.

The 3.8% net investment income tax

Under IRC §1411, a 3.8% tax may apply to net investment income, including gain on investment real estate, for individuals with modified adjusted gross income above the statutory thresholds: $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for married couples filing jointly. These thresholds are not indexed for inflation. A large sale can push you over them in the sale year even if you are usually below.

Whether NIIT applies depends on your facts. For example, the answer may differ for property used in a business you actively run. Ask your CPA.

Suspended passive losses

If rental losses were limited by the passive activity rules in prior years, those suspended losses generally become usable when you sell your entire interest in a fully taxable sale to an unrelated buyer. That can reduce the sale-year tax. Bring your carryforward schedule to your CPA.

Florida's tax picture

  • No personal income tax. Florida does not tax individuals on income, so individual owners, and owners of most pass-through entities, owe no Florida income tax on the gain
  • C corporations are different. Florida has a corporate income tax. If a C corporation owns your property, the sale is taxed differently at both the federal and state level, and getting money out of the corporation may be taxed again. Talk to your CPA
  • Other states can matter. If you live in another state, your home state may tax the gain. Florida property, out-of-state owner: check both

Closing costs on a Florida commercial sale

Who pays what is negotiable and stated in the contract. Local custom varies by county. Here is what to expect.

CostWhat it isWho usually pays
Documentary stamp tax on the deed$0.70 per $100 of consideration in most of Florida. Miami-Dade County uses a different rateCustomarily the seller in much of Florida, but negotiable
Owner's title insuranceInsures the buyer's title. Florida premium rates are set by state ruleVaries by county custom
Brokerage feeSet by your listing agreementSeller, under the listing agreement
Attorney feesContract review, closing documents, title curative workEach party pays its own
Settlement and closing agent feesThe title company or attorney handling closingOften split or by custom
Title curative workReleasing old liens, correcting recordsSeller, to deliver clean title
Survey updateIf the contract requires the seller to provide oneNegotiable
Loan payoff and prepayment costYour existing loan, plus yield maintenance or defeasance if anySeller
Recording feesRecording the deed and releasesVaries

Documentary stamp tax math

Doc stamps = sale price ÷ 100 × $0.70

On a $3,000,000 sale: $3,000,000 ÷ 100 × $0.70 = $21,000.

Transfers of interests in an entity that owns Florida real property can also trigger doc stamps in some situations. If you plan to sell the LLC rather than the building, ask your attorney first.

Prorations are not selling costs

Your closing statement will also show prorations: rent collected for days after closing, property taxes for the part of the year you owned the building, and tenant security deposits. These settle income and obligations between you and the buyer. They change your cash at closing, but they are not selling costs and they are handled separately for tax. Lesson 7 covers how they work, including why Florida property taxes paid in arrears usually mean a credit to the buyer.

FIRPTA: when the seller is foreign

Under the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act, if the seller is a foreign person, the buyer generally must withhold 15% of the amount realized and send it to the IRS under IRC §1445. The withholding is based on the gross price, not the gain, so it can be much larger than the tax actually owed.

What foreign sellers should do early:

  • Tell your closing agent and CPA at the start
  • Ask your CPA about applying for a withholding certificate, which can reduce withholding to the estimated actual tax. It takes time, so apply early
  • Expect the title company to hold or remit the funds at closing

U.S. sellers sign a certification of non-foreign status at closing. The closing agent will provide it.

A worked example: taxes and net proceeds on the Oviedo building

Illustrative numbers. Not market data. Tax rates in this example assume a high-income individual owner who held the property more than one year through an LLC taxed as a partnership. Your rates may differ.

The facts

  • Sale price: $3,000,000, closing June 15
  • Original cost in 2014 (including acquisition costs): $1,800,000
  • Capital improvements (new roof on two suites, paving): $150,000
  • Depreciation taken: $600,000 total
    • $520,000 straight-line on the building (unrecaptured §1250)
    • $80,000 on §1245 components from a cost segregation study
  • Loan payoff: $700,000, no prepayment penalty

Step 1: selling costs

CostAmount
Documentary stamp tax ($3,000,000 ÷ 100 × $0.70)$21,000
Brokerage fee (illustrative 4%)$120,000
Owner's title policy (illustrative; paid by seller here by agreement)$10,100
Seller's attorney$5,000
Settlement, recording, lien searches, estoppel processing$3,900
Total selling costs$160,000

Get real quotes. Use the Florida net sheet calculator to run your own figures by county.

Step 2: amount realized and adjusted basis

  • Amount realized: $3,000,000 − $160,000 = $2,840,000
  • Adjusted basis: $1,800,000 + $150,000 − $600,000 = $1,350,000

Step 3: gain

$2,840,000 − $1,350,000 = $1,490,000

Step 4: split the gain into layers

LayerAmount
§1245 recapture$80,000
Unrecaptured §1250 gain$520,000
Long-term capital gain ($1,490,000 − $80,000 − $520,000)$890,000
Total gain$1,490,000

Step 5: estimate federal tax

LayerAmountIllustrative rateTax
§1245 recapture$80,00037% (assumed top ordinary rate)$29,600
Unrecaptured §1250 gain$520,00025%$130,000
Long-term capital gain$890,00020%$178,000
NIIT on total gain$1,490,0003.8%$56,620
Estimated federal tax$394,220

Florida personal income tax: $0.

The estimated tax is about 26.5% of the gain ($394,220 ÷ $1,490,000). That is the money a 1031 exchange or another deferral path is trying to keep working. Lesson 5 covers those options.

Step 6: prorations and credits at closing

ItemCredit to buyer
Property taxes January 1 through June 15 (illustrative $36,500 a year, $100 a day × 166 days)$16,600
June rent collected for June 16-30 ($14,000 × 15 ÷ 30)$7,000
Tenant security deposits transferred$12,000
Total credits to buyer$35,600

Step 7: net proceeds

LineAmount
Sale price$3,000,000
Less selling costs−$160,000
Less loan payoff−$700,000
Less prorations and deposit credits−$35,600
Cash at closing, before tax$2,104,400
Less estimated federal tax−$394,220
Estimated cash after tax$1,710,180

The owner's "$3 million sale" becomes about $1.71 million of cash after tax in this example. The biggest single deduction after the loan is the tax, and the tax is the item most open to planning.

Common mistakes

  • Using the price as the number. Plan from net proceeds after tax
  • Forgetting depreciation. Recapture is taxed even if you never felt the deductions
  • Surprise from cost segregation. §1245 recapture can be taxed at ordinary rates
  • Ignoring NIIT. A large sale year can trigger it
  • No basis records. Long exchange chains and old improvements need documentation
  • Foreign seller learns about FIRPTA at closing. The withholding certificate process takes time
  • Planning tax after the contract. Deferral options must be set up before closing

What to take away

  • Gain equals amount realized less adjusted basis
  • Adjusted basis is cost plus improvements less depreciation taken or allowable
  • Federal tax comes in layers: §1245 recapture at ordinary rates, unrecaptured §1250 gain at a maximum of 25%, and long-term capital gain at 0%, 15%, or 20%
  • The 3.8% NIIT under IRC §1411 may apply above statutory income thresholds
  • Suspended passive losses generally free up on a full taxable sale
  • Florida has no personal income tax, but C corporations face Florida corporate income tax
  • Doc stamps on a Florida deed are $0.70 per $100 in most counties, and who pays is negotiable
  • Foreign sellers face FIRPTA withholding of 15% of the amount realized unless reduced
  • Prorations change cash at closing but are not selling costs
  • Build a net proceeds estimate with your CPA before you sign

Next lesson: Tax-Deferral Exits: 1031, Installment Sales, and More.

Get Market Insights Delivered

Weekly Central Florida CRE updates — cap rates, new listings, market trends, and investment opportunities. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.