Skip to content

Lesson 02 · 14 min read

What Your Commercial Property Is Really Worth

BOV, appraisal, BPO, and automated estimates compared; how buyers price income property and owner-user buildings; and how to spot an inflated number built to win your listing.

Every owner has a number in mind. Sometimes it came from a neighbor's sale, sometimes from a broker's flyer, sometimes from what the owner needs to retire. Buyers do not care about any of those. They price your property from its income, its risks, and what similar properties have sold for. The closer your expectations are to how buyers think, the faster and cleaner the sale.

This lesson covers the four kinds of value estimates and when each one fits, the three approaches to value, how buyers price income property and owner-user property, how to read a broker opinion of value (BOV), and how to spot an inflated number. It ends with a worked example on a net-leased building in Apopka.

Four kinds of value estimates

EstimateWho prepares itWhat it is forWhat to know
AppraisalA state-certified appraiserLending, estates, litigation, tax appeals, partner buyoutsFollows USPAP standards. Independent of the sale. Costs a fee and takes time
Broker opinion of value (BOV)A broker who wants to list or advisePricing and marketing strategy for a saleNot an appraisal. Shows how the broker would position the property with buyers
Broker price opinion (BPO)A licensed broker, often for a lender or servicerLoan workouts, portfolio reviews, quick valuationsA written opinion with comps and reasoning. Florida law does not let a broker call it an appraisal
Automated estimateA computer modelA rough starting pointWeak on commercial property because the model rarely sees your leases

When to use which

  • Thinking about selling: start with an automated estimate for a rough idea, such as the NNN property value estimator, then get one or more BOVs
  • Settling an estate, buying out a partner, or a tax appeal: get an appraisal. A BOV is a marketing document, and the other side will say so
  • A lender needs a quick, documented value: a BPO. See how a lender-grade commercial broker price opinion is built, with sales comparison, an income cross-check, and a written reconciliation

A BOV should still be built with the same discipline as a BPO: real comps, real income, and the reasoning written down.

The three approaches to value

Sales comparison

What have similar properties sold for? For commercial property, "similar" means more than size and location:

  • Same property type and use
  • Similar tenant credit and remaining lease term (for leased property)
  • Similar age, condition, and site features
  • Recent enough to reflect the current market

Comparables are adjusted for differences, then expressed per square foot, per unit, per acre, or as a cap rate.

Income approach

What is the income worth to an investor?

Value = Net operating income (NOI) ÷ Cap rate

Two methods:

  • Direct capitalization: one year of stabilized NOI divided by a cap rate drawn from comparable sales
  • Discounted cash flow (DCF): project several years of cash flow and a sale, then discount back. Used when income will change, such as a lease rolling soon or rent steps

Cost approach

What would it cost to build a replacement, less depreciation, plus land? Useful for new buildings, special-purpose property, and insurance. Buyers of leased investment property rarely rely on it, but it can support value for unusual buildings with few comparable sales.

A good valuation uses more than one approach and explains how they were weighted.

How buyers price income property

An investor buying a leased building is buying a stream of rent. The starting point is the cap rate on in-place NOI, the income the property actually produces today under its actual leases. Then the buyer adjusts.

Remaining lease term

More term usually means a lower cap rate and a higher price. Short term means the buyer prices the chance of vacancy, downtime, leasing commissions, and tenant improvement costs.

Tenant credit

A tenant with strong, rated corporate credit and a corporate guarantee is priced differently from a local operator or a single franchisee. Buyers read the guarantee carefully. A lease signed by a subsidiary with no parent guarantee is not the same as one backed by the parent.

Rent compared with market

  • Below-market rent: the buyer gets upside at expiration, but cannot collect it until then. Buyers rarely pay today for rent they cannot collect for years
  • Above-market rent: the income is at risk when the lease ends. Buyers may discount it, especially with short term left

Expense structure

Who pays taxes, insurance, and maintenance? An absolute net lease where the tenant pays everything, including roof and structure, is priced differently from a double net lease where the landlord keeps the roof, structure, and parking lot. The buyer is pricing the net income after the landlord's real costs, including reserves.

Deferred maintenance

Buyers deduct known repair costs from price, and often add a cushion for the unknown. A $45,000 parking lot problem can show up as more than $45,000 in a buyer's offer.

Where cap rates come from

Cap rates come from recent sales of comparable properties. They move with interest rates, credit markets, and demand for the asset type, and they differ by tenant, term, and location. This course does not state current cap rates. Get them from recent comparable sales, from brokers active in your asset type, and from appraisers. You can test how sensitive your value is with the cap rate calculator.

How buyers price owner-user property

An owner-user buys a building to occupy, such as a contractor buying a flex warehouse or a dentist buying a small office. They price differently:

  • Price per square foot compared with similar buildings that sold vacant or to users
  • Fit: clear height, loading, power, parking, office percentage, yard space, zoning
  • Cost to occupy: what they would pay to lease a comparable building, and what they would spend on improvements
  • Financing: many owner-users use SBA or bank loans, so the property must appraise

An owner-user may pay more than an investor for a vacant building that fits their business, because they are not pricing in lease-up risk. If your building could sell to either, your broker should test both buyer pools.

How to read a BOV

A BOV is an argument. Read it like one. Check each part:

Part of the BOVWhat a good one showsQuestions to ask
IncomeIn-place NOI from the actual rent roll and expensesIs any of this pro forma? Is vacancy or reserve included?
Cap rateA range supported by named comparable sales with datesAre these comps the same tenant type, term, and location?
Comparable salesAddress or description, date, price, cap rate or price per SF, key differencesHow were differences adjusted? Are there comps that were left out?
AdjustmentsSpecific dollar or rate adjustments for term, credit, conditionWhere did the deferred maintenance go?
ValueA range, plus a recommended list price or strategyWhat price would trade in a normal marketing period?
MarketingBuyer pool, method, expected timingWho are the likely buyers, and why?
AssumptionsStated clearlyWhat happens to value if one assumption is wrong?

The Underwrite, the BOV, and the Net Sheet in Course 22 shows how a broker builds one. Reading it from the agent's side will help you see what is supposed to be inside.

Spotting an inflated "buy the listing" number

Some brokers win listings by quoting the highest number. The plan is to sign a long listing term, then bring the price down after the market "speaks." By then your property has been on the market for months and buyers wonder what is wrong with it.

Warning signs:

  • The highest value with the fewest comps. A number with no support is a guess, or a hook
  • Market rent instead of contract rent. The BOV capitalizes the rent the tenant could pay, not the rent the lease says
  • Capital items missing. No mention of the roof, HVAC, or parking lot you know is due
  • Comps that do not match. Sales with stronger tenants, longer leases, or better locations
  • A single number, not a range. Real pricing has uncertainty
  • A long listing term tied to the high price. Ask why the broker needs 12 months if the price is right
  • "We can always adjust." Price reductions are not free. Days on market become part of your story

Ask any broker this question: "If a buyer offered your number, what would their lender's appraisal likely say?" If the broker cannot answer, the number may not survive the deal.

A worked example: a net-leased building in Apopka

Illustrative numbers. Not market data.

An owner has a single-tenant building in Apopka under a double net lease. Facts:

  • In-place NOI: $142,000 a year
  • Remaining term: 6 years, with rent increases only at renewal
  • Market rent analysis suggests the space could rent for enough to produce $165,000 of NOI today
  • Landlord's roof and parking lot. The roof is in good shape. The parking lot needs about $45,000 of work now
  • Local comparable sales with similar tenants and term suggest an illustrative cap rate range of 6.25% to 6.75%

Building the value

Cap rateIn-place NOIIndicated value
6.25%$142,000$2,272,000
6.50%$142,000$2,184,615
6.75%$142,000$2,103,704

Less the $45,000 parking lot cost:

  • Low: $2,103,704 − $45,000 = about $2,059,000
  • Middle: $2,184,615 − $45,000 = about $2,140,000
  • High: $2,272,000 − $45,000 = about $2,227,000

A reasonable BOV range is about $2,060,000 to $2,230,000, with a pricing strategy near the upper half if marketing reaches enough buyers. The below-market rent is a selling point to mention, but buyers will not pay today for income that starts in six years.

The inflated BOV

A second broker quotes $2,600,000. How did they get there? Divide the market-rent NOI by a rate slightly below the comp range:

$165,000 ÷ 6.35% = about $2,598,000, rounded to $2,600,000

Now look at it the way a buyer will. On the actual in-place NOI:

$142,000 ÷ $2,600,000 = 5.46% cap rate

And the buyer also inherits the $45,000 lot, so the real cost is $2,645,000, which is about a 5.37% cap rate. That is well below the comp range. Unless the broker can show sales at that level for similar tenants and term, this number is built on rent the tenant does not pay.

The owner-user check

Some buildings can sell either way. Suppose instead the owner has a 12,000 SF flex warehouse in Sanford and the tenant is leaving.

  • Illustrative user sales of similar buildings: $150 to $175 per SF
  • Indicated range: 12,000 × $150 = $1,800,000 to 12,000 × $175 = $2,100,000
  • Income cross-check: a stabilized market NOI of $145,000 at an illustrative 7.5% cap rate = about $1,933,000

Both methods land in a similar range, which gives the owner confidence. If they had been far apart, the broker should explain why and which buyer pool to target.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the broker with the highest number. Choose the broker with the best support
  • Pricing from what you need. Your payoff, your retirement goal, and your purchase price do not change what buyers pay
  • Forgetting the lender's appraisal. Most buyers finance. Their appraiser has to agree
  • Using an automated estimate as a list price. It is a starting point, not a strategy
  • Hiding deferred maintenance. Inspectors find it, and the price drop is larger later
  • Ignoring the owner-user market. A vacant or soon-vacant building may be worth more to a user than to an investor

What to take away

  • Appraisals, BOVs, BPOs, and automated estimates serve different purposes. Match the tool to the job
  • A good valuation uses more than one approach and explains the weighting
  • Investors start with a cap rate on in-place NOI, then adjust for term, credit, rent versus market, expense structure, and condition
  • Owner-users price per square foot, fit, and cost to occupy
  • Cap rates come from recent comparable sales. Get current data from active brokers and appraisers
  • Read a BOV like an argument: check the income, the comps, and the adjustments
  • An inflated number often capitalizes market rent or leaves out capital costs
  • Ask what the buyer's lender will appraise it at
  • A range with a clear strategy beats a single high number

Next lesson: Preparing Your Commercial Property for Sale.

Get Market Insights Delivered

Weekly Central Florida CRE updates — cap rates, new listings, market trends, and investment opportunities. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.