Skip to content

Lesson 06 · 14 min read

Choosing a Broker and Running the Sale

How to pick a broker for your asset type, which listing terms to read, how to choose between off-market, broad marketing, and a call for offers, and how to compare LOIs on more than price.

You have a value range, a prepared property, and a tax plan in progress. Now the sale itself. Two decisions shape the result more than any other: who represents you, and how the property goes to market. A good broker with the wrong strategy leaves money on the table. A good strategy with the wrong broker never reaches the right buyers.

This lesson covers how to choose a broker, the listing agreement terms an owner should read closely, the three main marketing approaches, the offering memorandum and confidentiality agreements, how to qualify buyers, how to compare letters of intent (LOIs) on more than price, and how to run a best-and-final round. It ends with three LOIs on the Oviedo building and how the owner chose.

Choosing a broker

Interview more than one. Ask the same questions of each, and ask for specifics, not adjectives.

What to look for

FactorWhat to askWhat a strong answer sounds like
Asset-type experienceWhat have you sold or valued that is like my property?Specific property types, locations, and the issues that came up
Buyer reachWho are the likely buyers and how will you reach them?Named buyer types: 1031 exchangers, private investors, users, local owners, national net-lease buyers
Marketing planWhat exactly will you do in the first 30 days?A dated plan: package, outreach lists, platforms, calls, tours
BOV supportHow did you get your number?Comparable sales, in-place income, adjustments, a range
CommunicationHow often will I hear from you, and in what form?A regular written activity report with buyer feedback
CapacityWho will actually do the work?Names and roles, and who answers buyer calls
RelationshipsHow will you represent me, and do you also work with buyers on this property?A clear answer about the brokerage relationship in writing

Florida law limits dual agency, and how a firm handles both sides of a deal should be clear before you sign. Ask the broker to explain it in writing.

Red flags

  • The highest price with the weakest support (see Lesson 2)
  • A marketing plan that is mostly "we'll put it on the platforms"
  • No questions about your leases, debt, or tax plan
  • Pressure to sign a long term before you have seen the plan
  • Vague answers about who does the work

Read the listing agreement

The listing agreement sets the term, the fee, and what happens if a buyer the broker introduced closes after the listing ends. Read every blank. The agent's side of the same document is covered in The Commercial Listing Agreement and Addenda, which is worth reading as an owner too.

Terms to check:

  • Type of listing. Exclusive right to sell, exclusive agency, or open
  • Term. A clear expiration date. Florida requires one in a written listing
  • Fee. The amount or formula, any minimum, and how a buyer's broker is paid
  • Tail period. How long after expiration the fee is protected, and whether it is limited to a list of registered prospects
  • Exclusions. Any buyer you already know who should be excluded, by name
  • Marketing costs. Who pays, any cap, and whether they are reimbursed
  • Early termination. Whether and how you can end the listing
  • Commission lien rights. Florida's Commercial Real Estate Sales Commission Lien Act (F.S. 475.700-475.719) can give a broker a lien on the owner's net proceeds when a commission is earned under a written agreement. The agreement must disclose it

Education, not legal advice. Have a Florida real estate attorney review the listing agreement and any purchase contract before you sign.

Three ways to take a property to market

ApproachHow it worksBest forTrade-offs
Off-market or targetedThe broker contacts a short list of likely buyers privatelySellers who value privacy, sensitive tenant situations, properties with an obvious buyerFewer buyers means less competition. You may not learn the market's best price
Broad marketingListed on commercial platforms, email campaigns, signs, broker outreachMost investment properties, where more buyers means a better priceTenants and competitors will know. Days on market become visible
Call for offersBroad or targeted marketing, then a firm date when offers are dueProperties with strong demand, sellers who want a clean comparisonNeeds enough interest to work. A missed date with few offers can hurt

Many sales combine approaches: targeted outreach first, then broader marketing, ending with a call for offers. The right mix depends on your property, your tenants, and how many qualified buyers exist.

Telling the tenants

Tenants will learn about a sale, especially during estoppels. Decide with your broker when and how to tell them. A tenant who hears about the sale from a buyer touring the property is a tenant who may cause trouble at estoppel time. Respect the lease's notice and access terms for showings.

The offering memorandum

The offering memorandum (OM) is the sales document for your property. A good one includes:

  • Executive summary: price or offer date, key investment points
  • Property description: site, building, parking, access, zoning
  • Tenant and lease summaries: term, rent, options, responsibilities
  • Financial summary: rent roll, in-place NOI, expense history
  • Location and market overview
  • Comparable sales and leases
  • Photos, site plan, and maps
  • Disclaimers and how to submit an offer

Everything in the OM should match your due diligence package from Lesson 3. If the OM promises more than the documents show, expect a re-trade.

Confidentiality agreements

Most sellers require a confidentiality agreement (CA, or NDA) before releasing the full OM, rent roll, and financials. It limits how a prospect can use your information and who they can share it with. The CA log also helps your broker track registered prospects for the listing's tail.

Qualifying buyers

A high offer from a buyer who cannot close is worth less than a fair offer from one who can. Before you spend weeks under contract, your broker should find out:

  • Proof of funds for cash buyers, or for the equity portion if financing
  • Lender status: a term sheet or a lender who knows the asset type
  • Track record: have they closed similar deals, and did they re-trade?
  • Decision-maker: who signs, and does an investment committee need to approve?
  • 1031 status: if the buyer is exchanging, has their sale closed and are the funds with a QI? When do their 45 and 180 days end?
  • Source of the deal: is this the buyer, or someone who plans to assign the contract?

The 1031 buyer

A buyer in an exchange can be a strong buyer. They have a deadline and money waiting. They can also be a risky one. If their own sale has not closed, their money may not exist yet. If their 45-day window is ending, they may identify your property and two others and pick later. Ask where they are in their exchange.

Comparing LOIs on more than price

A letter of intent sets the main business terms before the contract is drafted. Price is only one of them.

TermWhat to look atWhy it matters
PriceThe numberObvious, but only if the deal closes at it
DepositAmount, and whether there is a second depositSkin in the game
Hard money timingWhen the deposit becomes non-refundableBefore it goes hard, the buyer can walk freely
Due diligence periodLength, and extension rightsA long period ties up your property
Financing contingencyWhether the buyer can cancel if the loan failsA buyer with no contingency carries more risk
Closing dateDays after the end of due diligenceMatters for your 1031 and your payoff
1031 timingBuyer's or seller's exchange needsTight windows can help or hurt
AssignmentCan the buyer assign the contract?Unlimited assignment can mean you do not know who is really buying
ConditionsEstoppel thresholds, SNDAs, approvalsEach condition is a way out

Course 12 covers the buyer's side in Drafting the Letter of Intent (LOI).

Best and final

When you have several good offers, your broker can ask the leading buyers for their best and final offer by a set date. Tips:

  • Tell buyers which terms matter to you, such as a shorter due diligence period or earlier hard money
  • Give everyone the same deadline and the same information
  • Do not invent competing offers. Your broker should not either
  • Be ready to decide quickly. Buyers lose interest if a best-and-final round drags on

A worked example: three offers on the Oviedo building

Illustrative numbers. Not market data.

The owner listed the Oviedo building with a call for offers at a guidance price around $3,000,000. Three LOIs came in.

TermBuyer ABuyer BBuyer C
Price$3,080,000$3,000,000$3,025,000
Deposit$50,000$150,000$100,000
Hard moneyAfter 60-day DD$75,000 hard after 30-day DDAll hard after 45-day DD
Financing contingencyYes, 45 days after DDNone (cash, proof of funds)Yes, 30 days
Closing30 days after financing30 days after DD60 days after effective date
Days to closing (approx.)1356060
1031NoYes, funds with QI, 45-day window ends in 3 weeksNo
AssignmentUnrestrictedTo affiliates onlyTo affiliates only
Track recordNew buyer, unknownClosed similar propertiesLocal investor, lender pre-approved

How the owner reads them

  • Buyer A has the highest price, but $50,000 at risk, 105 days during which the buyer can walk, and unlimited assignment. The extra $80,000 over B is real only if A closes without a re-trade
  • Buyer B has the lowest price but the strongest terms: cash already at the QI, a short due diligence period, early hard money, and a deadline that motivates speed
  • Buyer C is in between, with a fair price and an approved lender, but a financing contingency

Best and final

The broker asks all three for best and final, telling them that certainty and timing matter. Results:

  • A raises the deposit to $75,000 but keeps the financing contingency and the long timeline
  • B raises to $3,040,000 with the same terms
  • C raises to $3,050,000 and drops the financing contingency, but keeps a 45-day DD

The owner picks Buyer B at $3,040,000. It is $10,000 below C, but B's money is already sitting with a QI, the deposit goes partly hard in 30 days, and closing is about two weeks sooner. The owner's own 1031 plan also benefits from a firm closing date. Price matters, but a closed sale matters more.

Lessons 4 and 5 used a $3,000,000 price for simplicity. At $3,040,000, the selling costs and the gain would both rise. Rerun the net sheet each time the price changes.

Getting help

MaxLife Commercial is a Central Florida commercial brokerage that represents owners selling investment and owner-user property. If you want to talk through pricing or strategy, see Sell Commercial Property in Florida, or for single-tenant net-lease owners, Sell Your NNN Property in Florida. Interview more than one broker either way.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring on price alone. Hire on plan, support, and buyer reach
  • Not reading the tail and exclusions. They decide who gets paid later
  • Going off-market by default. Privacy has a cost if it means fewer buyers
  • Releasing financials without a CA. Protect your information
  • Choosing the highest LOI without reading the terms. Look at deposit, hard money, contingencies, and assignment
  • Not asking a 1031 buyer where they are in their exchange
  • Dragging out best and final. Set a date and keep it

What to take away

  • Interview more than one broker with the same questions
  • Look for asset-type experience, real buyer reach, a dated marketing plan, and a supported value
  • Read the listing type, term, fee, tail, exclusions, marketing costs, and lien disclosure
  • Choose between off-market, broad marketing, and a call for offers based on your property and buyer pool
  • The OM must match your due diligence package
  • Require a confidentiality agreement before releasing financials
  • Qualify buyers on funds, lender, track record, and 1031 status
  • Compare LOIs on deposit, hard money timing, due diligence, financing, closing date, and assignment, not just price
  • Run a fair, fast best-and-final round
  • A slightly lower price with stronger terms can be the better deal

Next lesson: From Contract to Closing and After the Sale.

Get Market Insights Delivered

Weekly Central Florida CRE updates — cap rates, new listings, market trends, and investment opportunities. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.