Skip to content

Lesson 05 · 15 min read

Tax-Deferral Exits: 1031, Installment Sales, and More

The deferral paths to raise with your CPA before you sell: 1031 exchanges, DSTs and 721 UPREITs, installment sales, Opportunity Zone funds, charitable remainder trusts, and holding for a step-up.

Lesson 4 showed that tax can be the largest deduction from a sale after the loan payoff. In the Oviedo example, the estimated federal tax was about $394,000. Several paths can defer some or all of that tax, and one can eliminate the built-up gain for heirs. Each comes with rules, costs, and trade-offs, and most must be set up before closing.

This lesson covers the 1031 exchange from the seller's side, Delaware Statutory Trusts and 721 UPREITs, installment sales under IRC §453, Opportunity Zone investments, charitable remainder trusts, holding for a step-up in basis, and redeploying into net-lease property. It ends with the Oviedo owner comparing the paths side by side. Use it to build your list of questions for your CPA, not to pick a strategy on your own.

Education, not tax, legal, or securities advice. Tax rules change and depend on your facts. Confirm every strategy with your CPA and a Florida attorney before acting. DSTs, UPREIT interests, and Opportunity Zone funds are generally securities. Only a registered securities professional can recommend a specific offering. This course does not recommend any offering.

The 1031 exchange, from the seller's side

A 1031 exchange lets you defer gain on the sale of real property held for business or investment by reinvesting in other like-kind real property. Since the 2017 tax law changes, §1031 applies only to real property. Nearly any U.S. investment or business real estate is like-kind to any other, so you can sell a retail building and buy an industrial building, land, or a net-leased restaurant. A leasehold with 30 or more years remaining, including renewal options, is treated as like-kind to a fee interest under Treas. Reg. §1.1031(a)-1(c).

The rules a seller must plan around

  • Engage a qualified intermediary (QI) before closing. The exchange agreement and assignment must be in place before your sale closes
  • Never touch the money. Sale proceeds go from the closing agent straight to the QI. If you receive the funds, or can control them, the exchange generally fails
  • 45 days to identify. Within 45 days after your sale closes, you must identify replacement property in writing to the QI
  • 180 days to close. You must acquire the replacement within 180 days after the sale, or by the due date of your tax return for that year including extensions, whichever is earlier
  • No extensions for convenience. Weekends, holidays, and slow lenders do not stop the clock

Use the 1031 timeline calculator to map your exact dates from a planned closing date.

Replace value and debt

To defer all of the gain, the general targets are:

  • Buy equal or greater value than your net sale price (price less selling costs)
  • Reinvest all of the exchange cash held by the QI
  • Replace the debt you paid off, either with new debt or with added cash of your own

Boot

Anything you receive that is not like-kind property is called boot, and it is generally taxable up to the amount of your gain. Common forms:

  • Cash boot: proceeds you keep, or replacement property bought for less than the exchange cash
  • Mortgage boot: taking on less debt than you paid off, without adding cash to make up the difference
  • Non-qualifying expenses: some closing costs paid from exchange funds may be treated as boot. Ask your QI and CPA which ones

Rent prorations and security deposits credited to the buyer at closing can raise boot questions too. Some sellers cover those credits with outside cash. Ask your CPA how to handle them before closing.

Identification rules

Most sellers use the three-property rule (identify up to three properties of any value). Other rules allow more properties with value or acquisition limits. The detail is in 1031 Like-Kind Exchange Fundamentals, and Florida-specific points are on the 1031 exchange in Florida page.

Reverse and improvement exchanges

If you find the replacement before you sell, a reverse exchange lets an exchange accommodation titleholder hold one of the properties while you complete the exchange. If you want to build on or improve the replacement, an improvement exchange may work. Both are more complex and cost more. See Advanced 1031 Strategies.

DSTs and 721 UPREITs

Delaware Statutory Trusts

A Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) holds one or more properties. Investors buy beneficial interests. Under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, a properly structured DST interest can be treated as a direct interest in real estate for 1031 purposes. Sellers use DSTs as a passive replacement or as a backup when they cannot find enough direct property within 45 days.

What to know:

  • DST interests are securities. They are typically sold through broker-dealers. Only a registered securities professional can recommend one to you
  • You give up control. The sponsor manages the property and decides when to sell
  • They are generally illiquid. Plan to hold until the sponsor sells
  • Fees and structure vary. Read the offering documents with your own advisors

721 UPREITs

Under IRC §721, you may be able to contribute property, or in some programs a DST interest, to a REIT's operating partnership in exchange for operating partnership units, generally without current tax. The units may pay distributions and can later be converted to REIT shares.

What to know:

  • This is also a securities transaction. A registered securities professional must be involved
  • Converting or redeeming units is generally taxable
  • It is usually a one-way door. Once you hold partnership units, you generally cannot 1031 exchange out of them

Installment sale under IRC §453

In an installment sale, you finance part of the price yourself. The buyer pays a down payment at closing and the rest over time under a promissory note secured by a mortgage on the property. You generally report gain as you receive principal payments, instead of all in the year of sale.

How it works

  • Gross profit percentage. Each principal dollar you receive is partly return of basis and partly gain. Your CPA computes the percentage
  • Interest is ordinary income. The buyer pays you interest on the note. That interest is taxed as ordinary income each year
  • Recapture is recognized in the year of sale. Under §453(i), depreciation recapture that is taxed as ordinary income, such as §1245 recapture on cost-segregated components, must be reported in full in the year of sale, even if you receive little cash that year
  • Large balances can carry an extra charge. Under §453A, very large installment obligations can trigger an interest charge on the deferred tax. Ask your CPA whether yours would

The risks

  • Buyer credit risk. You are now the lender. If the buyer stops paying, you may have to foreclose and take the property back, possibly in worse condition
  • Your existing loan. Most commercial loans must be paid off at sale. The down payment usually needs to cover your payoff and closing costs
  • Cash and tax mismatch. Year-of-sale tax on recapture and on the gain portion of the down payment can be larger than the cash you keep
  • Loan terms matter. Interest rate, amortization, balloon date, personal guarantees, and default remedies should be drafted by a Florida attorney

Seller financing can also help the sale itself, because it can widen the buyer pool and support price. Weigh that against the credit risk.

Qualified Opportunity Zone investments

The Opportunity Zone program lets investors defer capital gains by investing the gain, not the full sale proceeds, in a Qualified Opportunity Fund within a set window after the sale, with additional benefits for long holding periods. Funds invest in designated low-income census tracts.

Congress made the program permanent in 2025 and changed it for investments made after December 31, 2026. Under the original rules, a deferred gain comes due at the end of 2026. Under the new rules, the deferral rolls for five years from each investment, the deferred gain can be reduced by 10% after five years (30% for qualified rural funds), and a new zone map takes effect January 1, 2027. Course 21, lesson 4 compares the two sets of rules. Confirm current rules, deadlines, and how they fit your sale with your CPA. Opportunity Zone fund interests are generally securities, so the same rule applies: only a registered securities professional can recommend one.

Charitable remainder trust

A charitable remainder trust (CRT) is an irrevocable trust. You transfer the property to the trust before any binding sale agreement, the trust sells it, and because the trust is generally tax-exempt the sale does not trigger immediate tax inside the trust. The trust pays you, or you and your spouse, an income stream for life or a term of years, and what remains goes to charity at the end. You may also get a charitable income tax deduction. The trade-off is real: the property and its remainder go to charity, not your heirs, and the transfer cannot be undone. Timing is critical, because transferring after the sale is effectively agreed can defeat the benefit. This is attorney work from the first conversation.

Holding for a step-up in basis

Sometimes the best exit is not selling. Under IRC §1014, heirs who inherit property generally receive a basis equal to its fair market value at the date of death. The built-up gain, including deferred gain from earlier 1031 exchanges and depreciation taken, is generally not taxed as income. If the heirs sell soon after, there may be little or no income tax.

This is why some long-time exchangers "swap until you drop." Points to weigh:

  • Estate tax is separate. Large estates may owe federal estate tax regardless of income tax basis
  • The property has to be manageable. Heirs inherit the leases, the roof, and the partners
  • Ownership structure matters. How the property is titled (individually, in an LLC, in a trust) affects the result
  • Plan with an estate attorney and CPA. Rules may change, and this is not a do-it-yourself area

Redeploying into net-lease property

Many sellers exchange from a management-heavy property into net-leased property where the tenant pays most expenses. The goal is often simpler income, a longer lease, and stronger tenant credit, while keeping the gain deferred. The replace your income with NNN page walks through that approach, and after the exit covers deploying proceeds when you are also selling a business.

A net-lease replacement still needs underwriting: tenant credit, remaining term, rent bumps, landlord responsibilities, and location. Do not let the 45-day clock push you into a property you would not buy without the tax deadline.

A worked example: comparing paths for the Oviedo owner

Illustrative numbers. Not market data. From Lesson 4: $3,000,000 price, $160,000 selling costs, $700,000 loan payoff, $35,600 credits to buyer, $1,490,000 gain ($80,000 §1245, $520,000 unrecaptured §1250, $890,000 capital gain), estimated federal tax $394,220.

Path 1: sell and pay the tax

Cash after estimated tax: about $1,710,180. Simple and liquid.

Path 2: full 1031 exchange

  • The QI receives cash at closing of $2,104,400
  • The owner buys a net-leased property for $3,100,000, at least the $2,840,000 net sale price
  • Funding: $2,104,400 from the QI plus a new loan of $995,600 ($2,104,400 + $995,600 = $3,100,000)
  • New debt of $995,600 replaces the $700,000 paid off
  • Result: the gain is generally deferred, and the owner has about $2.1 million of equity working instead of about $1.7 million

The deferred gain carries into the new property through a lower basis. It is not forgiven unless something like a step-up happens later.

Path 2b: partial exchange

The owner buys a $2,600,000 property instead. That is $240,000 short of the $2,840,000 net sale price, and generally about $240,000 of gain would be taxable as boot. The rest stays deferred.

Path 3: installment sale

  • The buyer pays $1,000,000 down. The owner carries a $2,000,000 note with interest
  • From the down payment, the owner pays the $700,000 loan, $160,000 of selling costs, and $35,600 of credits, keeping $104,400
  • Year of sale, under §453(i): the $80,000 of §1245 recapture is reported in full
  • The remaining $1,410,000 of gain is spread over principal received. $1,410,000 ÷ $3,000,000 contract price = 47%
  • Year-of-sale gain: $80,000 + (47% × $1,000,000) = $550,000

At the Lesson 4 rates, the tax on $550,000 of gain is well over the $104,400 of cash the owner kept. Even at the lowest rate in that example plus NIIT, $470,000 × 23.8% alone is $111,860. The owner would need cash from elsewhere for the sale-year tax, which is exactly the mismatch to check before choosing this path.

Side-by-side

PathTax nowEquity workingControlMain risk
Sell and payAbout $394,000About $1.71M, liquidFullTax cost
Full 1031Generally noneAbout $2.1M in real estateFull, if direct property45/180-day deadlines, buying the wrong property
Partial 1031Tax on bootMost of $2.1MFullSame, plus some tax
1031 into DSTGenerally noneIn a securitySponsor controlsIlliquidity, sponsor risk
Installment saleSpread out, recapture up frontIn a noteLender roleBuyer default, cash-tax mismatch
Hold for step-upNone nowStays in the buildingFullLease, roof, and management stay with you

The right path depends on the owner's age, income needs, estate plan, appetite for management, and how much the owner trusts a buyer as a borrower. That conversation belongs with a CPA and an attorney.

Common mistakes

  • Calling a QI after closing. Too late. The exchange must be set up before the sale closes
  • Touching the proceeds. Even briefly
  • Starting the replacement search at closing. Start before you list
  • Forgetting the debt. Paying off more debt than you take on, without adding cash, can create boot
  • Buying a bad property to beat the clock. A deferred tax on a losing investment is not a win
  • Seller financing without underwriting the buyer. You are the bank now
  • Trusting old Opportunity Zone summaries. The program changed in 2025
  • Treating a DST as a real estate purchase. It is a security, with securities rules and risks

What to take away

  • Most deferral paths must be set up before closing
  • A 1031 requires a QI, no touching the funds, 45 days to identify, and 180 days to close
  • To defer all gain, buy equal or greater value, reinvest all exchange cash, and replace the debt
  • Boot is generally taxable up to the gain
  • DSTs and 721 UPREIT interests are securities. Only a registered securities professional can recommend one
  • An installment sale spreads gain, but §453(i) recapture is recognized in the year of sale and interest is ordinary income
  • Seller financing makes you the lender, with credit risk
  • The Opportunity Zone program changed in 2025. Confirm current rules with your CPA
  • A charitable remainder trust is irrevocable and must be in place before a binding sale
  • Holding until death can give heirs a step-up in basis under IRC §1014
  • Underwrite any replacement property as if there were no deadline

Next lesson: Choosing a Broker and Running the Sale.

Get Market Insights Delivered

Weekly Central Florida CRE updates — cap rates, new listings, market trends, and investment opportunities. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.