Lesson 07 · 15 min read
Choosing Your Path: A Florida Parcel Case Study
One hypothetical 3-acre Lake County corner, four paths over 20 years: sale, ground lease of two pads, build-to-suit, and joint venture, with consistent numbers, the non-financial factors, and what to bring to your advisors.
The earlier lessons took each path apart. This one puts them side by side on a single parcel with a single set of assumptions, so the tradeoffs show up in dollars. The parcel is hypothetical. The method is what you can reuse on any piece of land.
You will see the four paths modeled over about 20 years, a summary table, the factors that numbers miss, a checklist of what to bring to a broker, attorney, and CPA, and how a commercial land broker fits into the process.
Education, not tax, legal, or investment advice. All figures are illustrative and before income tax. Confirm tax and legal questions with your CPA and a Florida attorney.
The parcel
Illustrative. A hypothetical property, not a real listing.
- Location: a hard corner at a signalized intersection on a growing arterial in south Lake County
- Size: 3.0 gross acres; about 2.4 usable acres after stormwater and access
- Zoning: commercial, with water and sewer at the property line
- Current use: pasture, in agricultural classification
- Owners: two siblings who inherited it; neither needs cash immediately, both want income, one cares about keeping it in the family
- Market interest: a buyer has offered $2,400,000 for the whole parcel; two pad users have asked about ground leases; a national retailer's developer has asked about a build-to-suit; a local developer has proposed a joint venture
Corners like this are what tenants look for. For how investors and users view them, see commercial corner lots.
Common assumptions
- All numbers are before income tax
- Lump sums are assumed reinvested in income property at an illustrative 6% annual return, with no growth, to make the paths comparable
- Escalations are 10% every 5 years
- The 20-year window runs from today; year 1 is spent on approvals and construction where a path needs it
Path A: sell the parcel
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $2,400,000 |
| Commission (illustrative 6%) | −$144,000 |
| Documentary stamp tax ($0.70 per $100) | −$16,800 |
| Title, survey, legal, other | −$20,000 |
| Net proceeds | $2,219,200 |
Reinvested at an illustrative 6%, that produces $133,152 a year, or $2,663,040 over 20 years. At year 20, the siblings own whatever they bought with $2,219,200.
What the table hides: if they pay tax on the gain instead of doing a 1031 exchange, they have less to reinvest. With an inherited basis, the gain may be modest. Lesson 6 covers the questions to ask.
Path B: ground lease two pads
The siblings carve the usable land into two pads and lease both, unsubordinated and net.
- Owner's site work: shared access drive, stormwater pond, and utility extensions: $450,000, paid in year 1
- Pad 1, a quick-service restaurant: $95,000 per year
- Pad 2, a coffee drive-thru or bank: $75,000 per year
- Rent starts: year 2, after permits and construction
- Term: 20-year base term each, with tenant renewal options
Combined rent schedule:
| Calendar years | Lease years | Combined annual rent | Rent over the period |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Before rent | $0 | $0 |
| 2 to 6 | 1 to 5 | $170,000 | $850,000 |
| 7 to 11 | 6 to 10 | $187,000 | $935,000 |
| 12 to 16 | 11 to 15 | $205,700 | $1,028,500 |
| 17 to 20 | 16 to 19 | $226,270 | $905,080 |
| Total | $3,718,580 |
Less the $450,000 of site work, net cash over 20 years is $3,268,580.
The leased fee value
Using the method from Lesson 3, value the two leases at rent commencement over the full 20-year base term, with a reversion of the land at $2,400,000 grown 2% a year for 20 years (about $3,566,274):
| Discount rate (illustrative) | Leased fee value |
|---|---|
| 6.5% | about $3,106,800 |
| 7.0% | about $2,930,300 |
| 7.5% | about $2,767,500 |
At every rate shown, the leased fee, before any selling costs, is worth more than the $2,219,200 net sale proceeds, even after subtracting the $450,000 of site work. That is the ground lease case in one line: the owners keep the land, collect more income, and hold an asset they could sell later if they choose. The cost is a 20-year landlord role, tenant risk, and less cash today.
Path C: build-to-suit
A national retailer's developer would lease a 10,000-square-foot single-tenant building on the whole usable site if the siblings build it.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Land at market value | $2,400,000 |
| Hard and soft costs, including construction interest and contingency | $3,000,000 |
| Total project cost | $5,400,000 |
| Tenant NNN rent, year 2 | $405,000 |
| Yield on cost | 7.5% |
| Value at an illustrative 6.5% market cap rate | $6,230,769 |
| Value created | $830,769 |
Financing, simplified:
- Construction and permanent loan: $1,950,000 (65% of the hard and soft costs), interest-only at an illustrative 7% for simplicity: $136,500 a year. Real loans usually amortize and must be refinanced
- Owners' cash: $1,050,000, plus the land
- Personal guaranty: likely required
Rent over 20 years:
| Calendar years | Annual rent | Rent over the period |
|---|---|---|
| 2 to 6 | $405,000 | $2,025,000 |
| 7 to 11 | $445,500 | $2,227,500 |
| 12 to 16 | $490,050 | $2,450,250 |
| 17 to 20 | $539,055 | $2,156,220 |
| Total | $8,858,970 |
Less 19 years of interest ($2,593,500), rent after interest is $6,265,470. Less the owners' $1,050,000 of cash, net is $5,215,470. At year 20 they own the land and a 19-year-old building and still owe $1,950,000.
This is the highest-income path by a wide margin. It also asks the siblings to raise $1,050,000, sign a guaranty, and manage a construction project. If costs had run 10% over, about $300,000 more, yield on cost would drop to roughly 7.1% and more than a third of the value created would disappear.
Path D: land contribution joint venture
A local developer proposes a small retail center.
- Total project cost: $8,000,000, including the land at an agreed $2,400,000
- Construction loan: $4,800,000, interest-only at an illustrative 7%: $336,000 a year
- Equity: $3,200,000. Siblings $2,400,000 in land (75%). Developer $800,000 cash (25%)
- Stabilized NOI from year 3: $640,000 (8% yield on cost)
- Cash flow in years 3 to 5: $640,000 − $336,000 = $304,000 a year
- Waterfall: 8% simple preferred return, accrued; return of capital; then residual split 50/50, which gives the developer a promote above its 25% share
- Exit: sale at the end of year 5 at an illustrative 6.75% cap rate, 3% selling costs
Sale price = $640,000 ÷ 6.75% ≈ $9,481,481
Net of 3% costs ≈ $9,197,037
Less loan of $4,800,000 = $4,397,037 to the partners
| Step | Total | Siblings (75%) | Developer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preferred return accrued, 5 years | $1,280,000 | $960,000 | $320,000 |
| Paid from cash flow, years 3 to 5 | $912,000 | $684,000 | $228,000 |
| Paid at sale (remaining pref) | $368,000 | $276,000 | $92,000 |
| Return of capital at sale | $3,200,000 | $2,400,000 | $800,000 |
| Residual at sale, split 50/50 | $829,037 | $414,519 | $414,519 |
| Total received | $3,774,519 | $1,534,519 |
The siblings receive $684,000 during operations and $3,090,519 at sale. Reinvested at the illustrative 6% for years 6 to 20, the lump sum produces $185,431 a year, or $2,781,467. Total income over 20 years: $684,000 + $2,781,467 = $3,465,467.
What the table hides: no income for two years, a land value that is gone if the project fails, and a partnership interest that cannot be 1031 exchanged directly. A sale at a higher cap rate, as Lesson 5 showed, shrinks the margin quickly.
The four paths side by side
Illustrative. Before income tax.
| A. Sell | B. Ground lease | C. Build-to-suit | D. Joint venture | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner cash at start | +$2,219,200 (reinvested) | −$450,000 | −$1,050,000, plus a $1,950,000 loan | $0 (land contributed) |
| Lump sum later | None | None | None | +$3,090,519 in year 5 (reinvested) |
| Income in year 2 | $133,152 | $170,000 | $268,500 after interest | $0 |
| Total income, years 1 to 20 | $2,663,040 | $3,718,580 | $6,265,470 after interest | $3,465,467 |
| Income less owner cash put in | $2,663,040 | $3,268,580 | $5,215,470 | $3,465,467 |
| Held at year 20 | Property bought for $2,219,200 | The land, two leases, reversion ahead | Land and building, $1,950,000 owed | Property bought for $3,090,519 |
| Owner effort | Lowest | Low | High | Medium |
| Risk to the land | None (sold) | Low, if unsubordinated | Lender can foreclose | Lender can foreclose |
Read it carefully:
- C looks best on income, but it is the only path where the owners borrow, guarantee, and build
- B beats A on income and keeps the land, for a $450,000 investment and a landlord role
- D ends with the largest lump sum, if the project works and the exit market cooperates
- A is the only path with no further risk to the owners, and the only path with real cash in hand today
- The 6% reinvestment rate drives A and D. Change it and the comparison changes
What the numbers miss
- Family goals. One sibling wants legacy; B keeps the land in the family. A and D do not
- Who manages it. B needs someone to handle estoppels, tax proof, and consents for decades. C needs a lot more. Is there a successor?
- Age and estate plans. If an owner is older with low basis, the step-up discussion in Lesson 6 may favor B
- Agricultural classification. Development ends agricultural classification on the developed acreage. Under a net lease the tenant pays the higher tax once rent starts, but the owners may carry it during approvals and construction
- Market timing. Today's offer reflects today's market. B and C are exposed to tenant risk over decades; D is exposed to the exit market in year 5
- Partner trust. D depends on one developer's skill and honesty
- Liquidity. A gives cash now. B can be converted to cash later by selling the leased fee. C and D are harder to unwind
- Hybrids. The owners could ground lease one pad and sell the other, or ground lease both and later sell one leased fee
For a starting look at any parcel's numbers, the land deal analyzer can help you organize assumptions before the advisor meetings.
What to bring to the broker, attorney, and CPA
- Survey: boundary or ALTA survey showing easements, encroachments, and access
- Title: a current title commitment, with any restrictions, easements, or liens
- Zoning and future land use: a verification letter from the city or county, and any planned road projects
- Utilities: availability letters for water, sewer, and power, with connection costs if known
- Access: existing driveway and median openings, and who controls the road (FDOT, county, or city)
- Environmental and site conditions: any Phase I reports, wetland delineations, flood zone, and soils information
- Agricultural status: the property appraiser's record and the latest TRIM notice
- Tax basis: purchase documents, estate valuation if inherited, and records of improvements
- Existing debt: loan documents, and whether the lender allows a ground lease or a partial release
- Authority: deeds, trust documents, letters of administration, or LLC records showing who can sign
- Every offer and LOI received, with dates
- A written list of each owner's goals, in their own words
How MaxLife Commercial helps landowners
MaxLife Commercial is a Central Florida commercial real estate brokerage that works with landowners on land sales, pad marketing, and ground lease transactions. We can help you study what your land can become, put the four paths on paper with current market inputs, market pads to tenants, and negotiate business terms alongside your Florida attorney and CPA. We do not give tax or legal advice. To see the kinds of sites we work with, browse Central Florida land for development.
What to take away
- Compare all four paths on the same parcel with the same assumptions before answering any offer
- A sale gives the most cash today and ends both risk and upside
- A ground lease can produce more income than a reinvested sale and keeps the land, in exchange for a landlord role and some site work
- A build-to-suit can produce the most income, but only for owners who can fund, guarantee, and manage construction
- A joint venture can produce the largest lump sum, but income starts late and the land is at risk
- Reinvestment rates, cap rates, and discount rates drive the comparison; get current numbers from the market, not a course
- Family goals, succession, estate plans, agricultural classification, and partner trust can outweigh the math
- Hybrids, such as leasing one pad and selling another, are often the right answer on larger parcels
- Bring survey, title, zoning, utilities, access, environmental, ag status, basis, debt, and authority documents to your advisors
Next: Course complete. Continue with Course 18: Land & Development Process to go deeper on entitlements and feasibility, or Course 21: Tax Strategy & 1031 Exchanges to plan the tax side of a sale or exchange.